Western Digital Black2 Dual Drive Review
WD Black2 Dual Drive
Manufacturer: Western DigitalUK Price: £234
US Price: $299
On the surface, Western Digital’s WD Black2 Dual Drive (WD1001X06XDTL) appears to be simply yet another version of the same hybrid storage idea that’s been floating around for a few years now: have a small SSD for fast access backed up by a large HDD, all in the same package. However, the trick to WD’s latest product is that instead of using the SSD as an invisible, high-speed cache here the two are kept separate. In one drive you literally get a 120GB SSD and a 1TB hard drive.
What’s the advantage of this? Well, first and foremost, most hybrid drives have only 4-8GB of cache whereas the Black2 has a full 120GB. It also means you get to decide what data goes on which drive and you get the performance of an SSD at all times. For instance on a hybrid drive overall transfer speeds are little better than a standard 5,400rpm hard drive because the cache is already full of all your most used programs. With the Black^2, though, you can read and write to the SSD at full pelt. All told, it should theoretically be the ideal speed and capacity upgrade for a laptop or small form factor system.
Retailing for a hefty ~£230, this drive clearly carries a premium over the cost of buying both a 1TB HDD and a 120GB SSD, so is heavily reliant on selling the message of convenience and, ultimately, being the only solution out there to offer what it does.
Acknowledging this premium price, Western Digital presents the Black2 Dual Drive in a very fancy box with a magnetic clasp and an extra outer sleeve. Inside is a hefty printed quick install manual, a comically oversized USB drive with the installation software (you can also just download it from the WD website) and there’s also a USB 3.0 to SATA cable included, for easily transferring files across before physically swapping your drives.
The drive itself is also rather more tarted up than your average hard drive. On its top a gold logo is painted on a glossy black plastic cover which is actually the backside of the SSD’s PCB sprayed black. The effect with the PCB traces marked out on the surface is rather funky.
Flip the drive over and we can see that the inclusion of an SSD has created quite a complicated front section to this drive. The SSD is sandwiched between the top surface and the metal bulk of the hard drive, with the hard drive PCB on the underside. Three screws are used to hold this front section of the SSD PCB in place but a rather less tinkering-friendly sticky foam is used to fix the rest of it to the back of the hard drive, making it too risky an operation to dismantle for photography. Essentially, though, it’s pretty clear Western Digital has really had to work to pack in all that tech.
The drive is a standard 9.5mm model which should fit all SFF systems and the vast majority of laptops, though some slim laptops use 7mm drives so be sure to check before taking the plunge.
Installation of the drive is the same as any other hard drive but until you’ve installed the Windows-only Dual Drive driver only the SSD will show up. Once the software is installed the HDD will appear as another partition. The utility works whether the drive is a primary or secondary drive though the HDD portion doesn’t work if connected over USB, so only your ‘boot data’ can be copied over before an upgrade when using a laptop (unless you connect both drives to another PC of course).
That really is it for features: this upgrade is all about its performance, so let's see how it stacks up.
Western Digital Black2 Dual Drive Review - Conclusion
Western Digital Black2 Dual Drive Review - Performance Analysis
What's immediately clear from our testing of the Black2 is that its SSD isn't the fastest around but that it does hold its own. Meanwhile the HDD portion of the drive is as slow as to be expected.The most clear Achilles heel of the drive is its sequential write speed, which is reported as 136MB/s in AS SSD. This is adequate - and a step up from a laptop HDD - but it clearly trails decent mainstream drives such as the Samsung SSD 840 250GB, which delivers 249MB/s. The story's similar in CrystalDiskMark, where the Black2 delivers 143MB/s compared to the Samsung 840's 256MB/s. As such, movement of any large files won't feel significantly faster on this drive than a normal laptop hard drive.
However, when it comes to delivering that crucial 'feel' of speed, which SSDs are desired for, the Black2's read speed delivers in spades. Again it falls short of most competing drives but with 405MB/s in AS SSD and 442MB/s in CrystalDiskMark it is only 50MB/s or so behind the fastest drives out there. The 114MB/s - 120MB/s speed of the HDD portion shows just what an upgrade the SSD portion provides.
Similarly, when it comes to random read and write speeds the SSD of the Black2 is right up there, at least at single queue depths, and if you ever needed more proof of just what an upgrade an SSD provides the comparative HDD scores here show it conclusively.
At higher queue depths the SSD of the Black2 does struggle a little in both read and write, but only compared to the latest top-end SSDs. Other more mainstream drives, again such as the Samsung Evo 840, it compares to very well indeed. Certainly for a laptop environment you're unlikely to be desperate for more performance.
Rounding things out, the Starting Applications Test of PCMark 7 again demonstrates how performance of the SSD portion of the Black2 is on par with other mainstream SSDs while the HDD is again so slow as for the number not to even show on our graphs. In the Gaming Test the HDD at least registers a comparable score of 3.8MB/s but the SSDs still trounce it, delivering around 16MB/s, with the Black2's SSD pretty much as fast as any other.
Conclusion
The Western Digital Black2 Dual Drive is certainly a mouthful to name but thankfully it's worth the effort as it really does deliver on being an ingenious upgrade for anyone out there with either a PC or laptop that only has room for one 2.5in drive. Its HDD is a little slower than performance 2.5in HDDs but that's where its SSD comes in to play, delivering performance that far outstrips any hard drive. It's not the fastest SSD, either, delivering performance somewhat on par with mainstream drives from last year, but it will still be a decent upgrade from any HDD.We're also convinced when it comes to Western Digital's strategy of separating the SSD and HDD, rather than having one act as a cache for the other.
However, there's no denying you're paying quite a premium for the convenience of having the speed of an SSD and capacity of an HDD in one drive. At ~£230 the Black2 is around £100 more expensive than buying a separate 120GB SSD and 1TB hard drive. So pricey is it, in fact, that you could buy a ~500GB SSD for the same money, and although that's still quite a step down in capacity we'd consider it enough for the vast majority of users.
As such the Black^2 is far from award worthy at the moment. If that price drops by £50, though, it'll be well worth a look.
-
Features15 / 15
-
Performance37 / 50
-
Value18 / 35
Overall Score - 70/100
0 comments:
Post a Comment